Letter 29: Cultivating Your Witness - Meeting Yourself in the Pause

“Not everything that is faced can be changed, but nothing can be changed until it is faced.”

— James Baldwin

---

Dear Future Human,

Pause with me. Take a deep breath in, then exhale for six seconds. Observe one sensation or feeling in your body and silently name it. You just created your Witness State.

Today we begin the practical work of rewiring your nervous system. We’ll start with the most important skill you’ll need to cultivate, your Witness.

Your Witness State is a quiet, conscious space you can enter at any moment—a still point inside your usual reactivity. From here, you can watch your patterns with curiosity instead of judgment and create the crucial gap between what you feel and how you respond.¹

As you read these words, notice that one part of you is reading while another part is aware that you’re reading. That’s your Witness—the part that can step back and observe without judgment. It lives beneath your thoughts, emotions, and automatic reactions.

This awareness has always been there. Your automatic patterns just move so fast that they obscure it. You become identified with your feelings, believing you are your anger, your fear, your joy.

As you learn to cultivate your Witness, you can begin to step back from your patterns. You won’t be able to erase them, but you can create a gap—a space to watch them operate without letting them run you.

Without access to the Witness, you stay caught in subconscious loops—reacting automatically without seeing how the machinery works. With access, you can observe, name, and map your inner terrain: your fears, triggers, the inner critic’s voice, the stories you tell, and the protective strategies that once kept you safe but now keep you small.

The Witness State creates the conditions for this kind of self-observation. It’s a space inside yourself where you can be honest with yourself without judgment or defense.

Transformation begins when you can see and feel what lives in you while recognizing these feelings and stories are part of you, not the whole of you. It will take some practice to feel successful, so be patient with yourself. Even noticing that you’ve been swept away after the fact, is already the Witness at work. Over time, your Witness will begin to recognize and see beyond old patterns and notice possibilities that used to be invisible.

Why catching reactivity is hard (and how to do it)

To cultivate the Witness, you need to intercept reactivity. Psychologist Daniel Kahneman’s description of the two cognitive systems, describes why this can be a very challenging endeavor.²

• System 1: fast, automatic, intuitive. It jumps to conclusions and triggers emotions before you’re aware of what’s happening. This is where childhood adaptations live, and it drives most daily responses.

• System 2: slow, deliberate, analytical. It can step back, question assumptions, and choose. But it’s metabolically costly, so the brain defaults to System 1 unless System 2 is consciously engaged.³

Your Witness is the part of you that can notice which system is running. It’s the observing presence that can see when you are on autopilot. Once you notice, you can invite System 2 online—to pause, reflect, and respond consciously.

Think of it this way:

• System 1 = automatic patterns (reactivity)

• System 2 = conscious, reflective capacity (the pause)

• Witness = the awareness that notices and chooses

At first, shifting from 1 to 2 feels effortful—like using an undertrained muscle. With practice, shifting becomes more natural and efficient.

It may feel hard or even impossible. That is normal. Remember this system is operating at a pace of milliseconds. Our nervous system was designed for survival, not reflection.

This is the heart of transformation: catching yourself in unconscious reactivity and choosing presence instead.⁴

Before you can live from the Witness, you have to PAUSE in the middle of a System 1 surge. That means beginning to observe and work with your nervous system’s rhythms.

How to develop Witness capacity

You can build this in three ways:

1. Daily practice to strengthen the “muscle.”

2. In-the-moment tools when you’re triggered.

3. Support structures that make success more likely.

1) Daily practice: build the muscle⁵

• Morning body scan (5–10 min).
  Sit or lie down. Eyes closed. Slowly scan from head to toe, noticing sensations without trying to change them: “Tension in my jaw… warmth in my chest… tingling in my hands.” You’re training observation without reflexive fixing.

• Pause reminders (3–5 times/day).⁶
  Set a simple prompt on your phone: “What am I feeling right now?” When it goes off, stop. Take three breaths. Notice body, emotion, and the story your mind is spinning. Don’t change anything—just notice.

• Evening reflection (5 min).
  Ask: When did I catch a pattern today? When did I miss it? What early body signals can I learn? This is about pattern recognition, be kind with yourself.

2) In the moment: when you’re triggered

• Step 1 — Start with your body, not your mind.
  Your body reacts before your thoughts do.⁷ Catch the early signals: heat in the chest, jaw clenching, shoulders tightening, breath shortening or holding, throat constricting. These arrive seconds before the full wave.

  When you notice one, pause:

  1. Hand on heart.

  2. One long exhale (twice as long as your inhale).

  3. Silently: “I’m triggered. I’m pausing.”

  This 5–10 second micro-pause interrupts the cascade and brings your Witness online and literally rewires you in that moment.⁸

• Step 2 — Name the feeling.
  Most reactions involve one or more of these:

  • Anger (a boundary feels crossed)

  • Fear (safety or worth feels threatened)

  • Shame (exposed, defective, “less than”)

  • Hurt (rejected, abandoned, unseen)

  Name it specifically: “I’m angry—and underneath, I’m hurt.”

• Step 3 — Name the story.
  Ask: “What story am I telling right now?” It will feel true in the moment; your body reacts as if it’s reality.

  Example: You text someone and they don’t reply. System 1 says, “I’m being ignored; I don’t matter.” System 2 can recognize, “They might be in a meeting—this may not be about me.”

• Step 4 — Reality check.

  Gently separate what’s happening from what your pattern perceives. The question isn’t “Are my feelings valid?” (they are). It’s “Am I reacting to the present, or to an echo of the past?” Once you can tell the difference, you can choose a response that serves you now.

• Step 5 — Choose your response.
  You have options:

  • Let the old pattern run (sometimes you still will).

  • Try a new, small behavior.

  • Or simply stay with the feeling without acting yet.
    The power is in having a choice at all.

3) Support structures: set yourself up to succeed

• Lower overall activation (widen your window).
  Think of your nervous system as a cup. If chronic stress keeps it 80% full—poor sleep, little movement, lots of stimulation—it overflows easily.⁹ Tend to basics, so that you start closer to 30% full:

  • 7–9 hours of sleep

  • Daily movement (even 20 minutes of walking)

  • Whole foods; minimize added sugar and alcohol

  • Laughter, play, and moments of joy

  • Time in nature

  • Meaningful connection

  Taking care of your whole self shifts your physiology and makes pausing easier.

• Partner with a Pause Partner.
  Pausing alone is extremely hard. Invite one or two trusted people to lend you their awareness.

  As Winnicott emphasized, real change happens within a “holding environment”—a relational space where another person can stay present without fixing or judging you.¹⁰ Over time, this kind of steady presence allows the nervous system to relax its defenses and creates space for the authentic self to emerge.

  Choose carefully. Pick someone you see regularly—where real triggers can come up. Someone who stays calm when you’re activated. Someone you trust not to throw this back at you later. And ideally, someone who’s working on their own stuff too.

  The setup conversation:
  “I’m working on noticing unconscious patterns. When you see me reacting in a way that doesn’t serve me, would you gently flag it? You can start by getting me to pause.

  Agree on a signal: a word (“pause,” “pattern,” “witness”), a gentle gesture (hand on shoulder), or a question (“What are you feeling right now?”).

  When they signal:

  1. Stop.

  2. Three breaths.

  3. Hand on heart.

  4. Check to see and name what you are feeling.

  5. See if you can identify a story associated with that feeling.

  6. Thank them. No fixing required—just awareness.

  Debrief later: “What did you notice? What was my body language or tone?” This teaches you to recognize the pattern earlier next time. You are most likely going to resist pausing at first—that’s normal. It may be hard to name feelings or the story—also normal. Stay with it. Your job is to keep discovering and learning what lives in you.

What progress actually looks like

You’ll miss almost all your reactions at first. That’s expected. Aim to move from 0% catches to 10%, then 30% and beyond. Each small success strengthens the pathway of conscious response.

You’re not trying to get rid of System 1—you need it for real emergencies, and it’s helpful most of the time. You’re just learning to notice when it’s running the show, and to bring in System 2 when that would actually help.

Cultivating the Witness takes time. Some days you’ll resist it. Other days you’ll be open. That’s normal. Keep at it and the capacity grows. It’s like learning a language—at first every word feels awkward and deliberate. With practice, it starts to flow. In this work, just noticing is progress.

Be gentle with yourself. You’re working with millions of years of evolution wired for quick survival responses. That wiring still protects you in true danger—but it doesn’t help with the complexities of modern relationships, work, and self-understanding.

Where this leads.

The Witness is the starting point. Once you can step back and observe, you can start asking: What patterns am I running? Where did they come from? How do they actually work? Next letter, we’ll map your specific circuitry, triggers, body signals, defenses and stories. You’ll begin creating your own pattern library.

For now, learn to pause. Everything else becomes possible from there.

With care and respect for your journey,
Ronit

1. M. Loncar and C. Fiskum, “Detached Self-Observation as a Practice of Wisdom: Psychological, Relational, and Civic Implications,” Frontiers in Psychology, October 2025.

2. Daniel Kahneman, “Thinking, Fast and Slow,” Farrar, Straus and Giroux, 2011.

3. Farnam Street, “Daniel Kahneman: The Two Systems,” Farnam Street Blog, retrieved January, 2026.

4. Jessica Koehler, “Embracing the Space: Growth and Freedom in Our Responses,” Psychology Today, May 2024.

5. M.S. Akash et al., “Small changes, big impact: A mini review of habit formation,” World Journal of Advanced Research and Reviews, 2025.

6. Ronit Herzfeld, “Awareness App,” Ronitherzfeld.com, 2011.

7. Tyson Aflalo, “New Insights into the Neuroscience Behind Conscious Awareness of Choice,” Caltech, April 2022.

8. James R Langabeer PhD, “How Strategic Pauses Improve Decisions in Life Transitions,” Psychology Today, December 2025.

9. Harvard Health Publishing, “Understanding the Stress Response,” Harvard Health Online, April 2024.

10. D.W. Winnicott, “The Theory of the Parent-Infant Relationship,” International Journal of Psycho-Analysis, pp. 585-595, 1960.

---